Decanter, aerator, carafe
| Compared | Decanter | Aerator pourer | Carafe |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it does | Air and sediment removal | Quick air as you pour | Serves the wine |
| Removes sediment | Yes | No | Yes, if you pour slowly |
| Air for a young red | The most, over time | A little, straight away | Some, less than a wide decanter |
| Best for | Big young reds, old reds | Tonight's young red | House wine, water, serving |
| Price level | $$ to $$$$ | $ | $ to $$ |
| Cleaning | Needs care | Rinse after use | Easy |
What a wine aerator does
An aerator pourer sits in the neck of the bottle, or you hold it over the glass. As the wine runs through, it is mixed with air, so a young, tight red tastes a little more open right away. It is quick and small. What it cannot do is remove sediment or give the wine the long, slow opening a powerful young red gets from an hour in a wide decanter.
What a carafe is
A carafe is a plain jug, usually with a narrower body and no stopper, used to serve wine or water. It can leave sediment behind if you pour into it slowly, and it gives a wine some air, but less than a wide-base decanter.
Which one do you need?
- You drink young reds tonight, often: an aerator pourer is enough.
- You open big reds or old bottles: a decanter. See the best wine decanters.
- You mostly serve everyday wine to friends: a carafe looks good and is easy to clean.
- You want one thing that does it all: a wide-base decanter.
The picks
My picks come from the Amazon listings and from what a sommelier needs a decanter to do, not from a lab test. Price levels: $ budget, $$ everyday, $$$ mid-range, $$$$ premium. The button shows today’s price.
Decanter, aerator or carafe: your questions
Is an aerator as good as a decanter?
For giving a young red quick air, an aerator pourer does a reasonable job glass by glass. It cannot remove sediment and it gives less time in the air than a decanter, so for old wines and for big young reds a decanter is better.
What is the difference between a carafe and a decanter?
A carafe is a simple jug for serving, usually with a narrower body. A decanter is shaped for wine: often a wide base for air and a neck that pours cleanly. Either works for leaving sediment behind.
What is the point of a wine aerator pourer?
It adds air as the wine pours from the bottle into the glass, so a young, tight red tastes a little more open straight away.
Do I need both a decanter and an aerator?
No. If you drink young reds tonight and often, an aerator is enough. If you open old bottles or bigger reds, buy a decanter.
Keep reading
Some links on this site are Amazon affiliate links. If you choose to buy through them, a small commission may be earned at no extra cost to you.